YouTube Comments: The Ultimate Proof of Human Idiocy
August 11, 2008
Reading YouTube comments is like reading the text messages between a 13-year-old girl and a klansman.
Nowhere is it more evident the average citizen cannot handle the responsibility of an open forum.
YouTube’s core offering is great. It enables anybody to post and share videos ranging from humorous to inspiring. You can literally spend a lifetime sifting through entertaining videos.
With roughly 80 million videos and 3 billion video views, YouTube currently eats up more bandwidth than the entire internet in 2000.
With the masses comes idiocy, and intellects such as myself are subjected to the immaterial ramblings of teenyboppers and the offensive condemnations of racists.
The typical comment thread for a YouTube video starts innocently enough. Say we’re checking out something as harmless as a sneezing panda (20 million people have).
The comments start like this…
surferchick12: LMAO! the mom is like WTF!!!!!!!!111
xXxPokemonxXx: awww look at the baby panda ROFL ;) hahaha LOL
TonyBDaMan: 8===D
It then turns political…
GreenGi2l02: whats so funny about animals in captivity??
Dave-O: Stupid liberals always trying to free lame animals. Eat pandas.
Then a couple off-topic notes…
dancefreak66: The Peruvian government cuts down 1,300 acres of forest every day. Click here to stop them.
lovematenow: You have a secret crush! Paste this message into 8 other comment sections to learn who loves you!
And then it turns ugly…
the_answer3: 9/11 was great day ever. Americans burn with Bush’s actions. Your imperialism will be your end.
Eagleface: shut up you brit. you all have small pen1s and you know it!
ShaFeLeR00: Hang minorities.
YouTube tried fixing this by adding a voting system similar to Digg’s, but this only put a band aid on the problem. Google, who now owns YouTube, does a decent job filtering spam on its other platforms but not with YouTube.
You know its bad when programmers have to create scripts to hide the comments. We’re dealing with a larger issue of global idiocy and censoring some comments is only a start.
Only a masochist gets pleasure out of reading these things. But in a way, it’s like watching two morbidly obese women wrestle in a pool of baby oil—a horrendous sight, yet you just can’t look away.
Comments
61 Responses to “YouTube Comments: The Ultimate Proof of Human Idiocy”
Got something to say?
8===D
Yes, some times people act weired! Just have a look at this example from Yahoo! Answers:
http://i-blog-ul.blogspot.com/2008/07/i-have-no-words.html
Panda’s do taste good though…. The Puruvian government supplies them to George Bush’s secret crush. Before 9/11they came from small peckered brits. haahahhaa…
N1 yo.
NIFOC-
geekgyrl
WTF! PPLS CMNTS ON YOUTUBE ARE AWESOM U JUST DUN NO WHT YUR TALKIN BOUT!
Nah I’m just kidding… I agree >.< People do tend to get a little out of hand when commenting. I’ve seen so many comments that are worse than what I posted… well spelling wise anyways. Yay for ignorant teenies.
The tyranny of the idiocy of the majority. Did I get that about right?
Fuck YouTube comments.
The code is crap – i mean in a technical sense. The comments don’t display in “thread view” like Reddit.
sad… need I say more?
It is a little sad to watch youtube comments unfold. But it’s a very good metaphor with the fat ladies wrestling. Sometimes it’s just too fascinating to not keep reading.
I feel sad that so many people are idiots, though. I wish that would change somehow. Even if people just started writing words out again, I’d be happy. :(
I must admit I find the stupidity of Youtube comments absolutely hilarious. I am also guilty of going onto Youtube and deliberately being a jerk to everyone and starting fights. It’s a good way to kill time, and makes me laugh to think I made someone angry through the Internet.
^Dwayne,
I absolutely agree. I saw a Richard Pryor vid on YouTube once that had me crying with laughter, then just for shits and giggles I posted a comment saying he was rubbish and had stolen his style from Chris Rock (all in txt speak, of course).
People actually threatened to kill me. It was brilliant!
I agree that the comments do get a little outlandish. My comment for this post: Considering yourself an intellect….um, no.
To be fair, it’s not just Youtube, pretty much any site that allows comments can ruin the most interesting post. I’ve tried to force myself not to read the comments, but like you say; fat oily wrestling…can’t….stop….reading…..
^ Sam,
Yep, that’s Youtube alright. I think it’s pretty hilarious people get so offended when you quite clearly aren’t being serious.
You insult something and people are like “WTF N00B!” and when you really hurt them it’s more like “OwWwW! My MeGaHurtsz”.
Btw, I’m Dwayne Charrington, just changing up my name style.
George Bush doesn’t care about black people.
Fuck ur mother!
And you made a horrid remark about fat women.
You know what would be more disgusting? Watching two skeleton women who just got done puking up food they ate, wrestle in jello.
There are two sides to every story.
And, the people that come on to comments just to stay some stupid crap, are lonely and hated by their parents. This is their escape.
comments are my favorite part of webpages. don’t be dissin on them.
I don’t even look at the comments anymore for these exact reasons.
Yep. I am often entertained by youtube comments and often disgusted. It’s a mixed bag of good-natured idiots and bad-natured idiots. I love your Panda examples. Pefect.
I’m a Brit and if my pecker was big enough I would cram it into that foul mouthed blasphemer.
You have a very good choice of comments here. Thanks for your post, I enjoyed it immensely.
Cheers The Baldchemist.
WHOA, Stupid people?! On the internet?!
Go outside and start conversations with people. Most of them are stupid and ignorant. The difference is that in real life you can’t censor it away. (I know I know, North Korea, USSR, etc.)
I think it’s important to consider how little you know before opening your mouth.
Comments can ruin anything, For example,today I was on an art site. All of the commenters were like: how nice, that’s so neat.
It took one douchebag to say something nasty and ruin it.
youtubers are the worst. I wish the site would filter it better.
I agree. In fact, this is the reason why I do not allow comments on my site.
I am proud to consider myself at least partially responsible for Yahoo to cease allowing comments about news stories posted in their news section a year or so ago.
So much fun lambasting the multitude of idiots infesting this planet.
So much material to work with and a dictionary full of them word things to use while pounding upon the unending idiocy of the human herd.
Some of these comments are almost as bad as those found on youtube….ironic eh?
SHUT UP u fag dun be such a fag fag ass.
IF U H8 America why du live here fag?
(I hate youtube comments. They make me want to vomit)
Dear guise,
Shut up, and go back to hell where you and Lucifer go have an orgy.
I agree with this post. Youtube comments sucks. It’s best that we ignore it. Sometimes we wish we could punch them, which would be awesome on a computer. Because Youtube popularity is opened to ANYONE, especially with stupid peoples. But as we all know, since the internet is seriouse bussiness, we enter a state of RAGE!
As kids before the internet, we have T.V, and we listen to everything it said.
I think the problem is worse than a few bad comments. I know a lot of people delete their accounts and chosing another host, vimeo myspace ets…
the youtube comments section ( depending on the accompanying video of course ) resembles the wall of a toilet in the stupidest, most ignorant, bigotted, bitter & resentful town on Earth.
I recently watched a video of Irish travellers ( over 1 million views & a few thousand comments )…virtually every comment was littered with hateful racist language.
When watching youtube I try to make a point of not scrolling downward to see the predictable torrent of abusive dross that gets thrown up, like tags by the world’s worst graffiti artists.
[...] as someone else put it: "The Ultimate Proof of Human Idiocy" (worth a read for the tale of how a clip of a sneezing panda [...]
Spot on! On discovering youtube, I had a gigantic ego boost. Suddenly here was real evidence that I WAS truly, vastly more intelligent, than the greater proportion of the human race! I had known this theoretically for some time, (via Mensa) and intuition. At Last, though, here was undeniable PROOF.
Not only the racist, ‘fuck’ laden comments, but the huge number of misinterpretations of videos whose meanings were as clear as daylight! It was a huge revelation. I wonder how some of these people manage to remain alive!
It might be an ego-boost, but it.s a worry, too!
Having said that, I too, have a huge amount of fun teasing people on You Tube, and Oh it can be really hilarious, keep me laughing for days on end! A great source of entertainment! You Tube really does sort the wheat from the chaff. The vast majority seem to be chaff, nevertheless, freedom of speech is important, but then again, so is an education and clarity of thought.
Interesting post!
I agree. Every time i see youtube comments it makes me vomit. It looks like all the trash of the world or uneducated people have united to comment on youtube. You can easily find the racist, vulgarest and rudest comment on youtube. I can see form some of above comments that how proudly these commentators feels.
this online behavior happens in every site with no moderation
the human releases his primal (primate) instinct.
IRL moderation is the law
In the internetz moderation are the Admins
Youtube doesn’t moderate comments
fuk u fukin fagot im not stupid
Hey, this is kind of fun! I’m going to start doing this on YouTube just to inflame those dummies!
the comments are the best bit! seriously!
The comments section is the best ESPECIALLY when it’s a really charged subject (healthcare, abortion, etc). I’ll admit, I’m a troll. My favorite thing to do is to change my avatar to a klansman and start agreeing with extreme right people. It’s so funny reading the uncomfortable responses when they think the KKK is on their side.
your all a bunch of fucking nig nogs! youtube is lame this whole world is stuck on stupid! Grow up already!
You all can’t be fucking serious. As if ANYONE gives a fat oily chicks ass what any of you think.
[...] you can see, the web allows for a new kind of logic in [...]
this has to be a troll…
“I must admit I find the stupidity of Youtube comments absolutely hilarious. I am also guilty of going onto Youtube and deliberately being a jerk to everyone and starting fights. It’s a good way to kill time, and makes me laugh to think I made someone angry through the Internet.”
I do that all the time, well when I am bored.
Just a test to see how stupid some youtubers are lol, its highly amusing when someone though the doomsday landings happened in Germany.
Actually sent the dude a PM with where Normandy actually is, was the most histerical thing ever!
Chris Bech Norwayan Criminal master is drugs pushers in Tablas, Romblon island Philippines.
youtube comments like a secotr.. I cant believe this much has youturbe comments regardsç
youtube.. just perfect trade mark..
selimiye marmaris
“Dwayne Charrington on September 17th, 2008 3:46 am
I must admit I find the stupidity of Youtube comments absolutely hilarious. I am also guilty of going onto Youtube and deliberately being a jerk to everyone and starting fights. It’s a good way to kill time, and makes me laugh to think I made someone angry through the Internet.”
Sounds like you need to get a life mate.
I used to have an account on Youtube. Posted at least one good video there, most of them (four in total) only average. And then I end up in a troll war with someone from another country because I posted a think-piece, and obviously they either got confused, or were too dumb to get it, so they ended up fighting me across the comments. So I had to pull a Dunkirk and terminate my account here.
I think I’ll repost my better videos, but somewhere else where people aren’t so f***ing thick!
I always use youtube comments. It is very beneficial for every one.
Like you info, Nice, Good, Cool.
Youtube comments are the lowest form of human literature. It is incredible that such a large proportion of people that comment there seem to be absolute cretins.
I don’t know what’s worse, a bunch of idiots and racists or a bunch of jackasses posing as idiots and racists just to rile people up for their own enjoyment. Actually I do, the second one is worse.
[...] abused in the slightest, because the vast majority of the target demographic (internet users) are well-adjusted individuals, particularly the ones that would be willing to place calls to and receive calls from complete and [...]
Where ever we go we always find some self-appointed “intellectual” trying to censor things.
But youtube comments are just a reflections of the real world. Walk around and talk with people. Better yet, sit and listen to groups of folks talking. I traveled the whole world, by myself, for many years, like Caine without the martial arts skills or self discipline ;) I walked in the world’s parks and train stations by myself, ate and drank by myself, went to shows and clubs by myself. Not having anyone to talk to, I listened. I listened carefully for hours, days, years; first for entertainment, morbid curiosity, then out of a deep sadness. People are sick, the human mind is caught in a pattern of inane drivel, mindless words constantly, ceaselessly spilling out onto other people, never being quiet, always convinced of their own importance, their own validity, their own superiority. Rarely in all my travels has anyone not fit this bill anywhere in the world. YouTube comments just reflect what humans are: dull, mindless, cruel, hateful, petty, ignorant, sick.
Human suffering is common to all mankind.
I think that a thousand years from now, Martian historians will conclude that the downfall of our planet can be directly linked to YouTube comments.
Actually, who is responsible for it?
It is hilarious how bad some of the comments can get. YouTube comments need more moderation imo.
I’ve been using YouTube for as long as I can remember. And everytime I go to that site, EVERYTIME, I find some of the most ignorant, hateful tripe you can think of. I’ve heard it all, from people who think that race and heritage correlate to intelligence and status, to people who think the holocaust didn’t happen, to people who think the moon landing was faked.
I can’t even begin to tell you how dumb alot of the people on that site are. It makes you wonder what the hell is going on in these people’s minds and if they really think that way or not. It’s so bad that you actually can’t take anything on that site seriously, because you never know if you are reading something credible or just the bullshit ramblings of some uneducated prick.
It’s not all bad though. There are many people who are well aware of the crap that goes on and have tried to get the word out and bring these overwhelming idiots down. But there words have fallen on deaf ears, and from what I can tell YouTube is getting worse by the day. Now you can find softcore porn on the website for God’s sake. Let’s face it, the site is a lost cause.
I think most of YT commentators are “really” residing in mental institutions.